On June 16, 2025, Attorney General Matthew J. Platkin issued a statement regarding the U.S. Supreme Court’s order in the case of First Choice v. Platkin. The case involves First Choice, a crisis pregnancy center operating in New Jersey, which has been under scrutiny for allegedly not complying with state laws and potentially misrepresenting information about reproductive healthcare.
Attorney General Platkin explained that a lawful subpoena was issued to First Choice in November 2023 to ensure compliance with relevant state laws. He emphasized that non-profits, including crisis pregnancy centers, must not deceive or defraud residents of New Jersey and that the state has the authority to investigate such matters.
“The question before the U.S. Supreme Court focuses on whether First Choice sued prematurely, not whether our subpoena was valid,” stated Platkin. He expressed optimism about prevailing when the Supreme Court considers this issue in the fall.
Platkin also highlighted that First Choice is seeking an exception from standard procedural rules to avoid complying with the state’s subpoena, which he argued is not permissible under the U.S. Constitution. “No industry is entitled to that type of special treatment—period,” he asserted.
The Attorney General reaffirmed his commitment to enforcing fraud laws impartially against any entity that might harm or violate residents’ rights, regardless of its power or influence.
