Emily Seidel President and Chief Executive Officer | Americans for Prosperity
+ Legislature
B. B. Urness | Nov 27, 2024

Supreme Court decisions bolster civil liberties amid challenging year

Thanksgiving is often seen as an underrated holiday, offering a time for family gatherings, football, and food without the pressure of gift-giving. It also serves as a moment to reflect on gratitude, which studies suggest can benefit both physical and mental health.

In 2024, amidst various challenges, several key events have had significant impacts on civil liberties in the United States. One notable development was the Supreme Court's unanimous decision in NRA v. Vullo in May. The ruling determined that New York officials could not use their influence over insurance companies to limit coverage for Second Amendment advocates based on their speech. Justice Sotomayor emphasized that "a government official cannot coerce a private party to punish or suppress disfavored speech on her behalf."

Religious liberty also saw victories this year with successful cases led by The Becket Fund and Alliance Defending Freedom. These included wins for Jewish students at UCLA and Christian high school students in D.C., as well as Jack Phillips in Colorado.

The constitutional right to due process was reinforced when the Supreme Court ruled in Securities and Exchange Commission v. Jarkesy that Americans must have access to an independent judge rather than facing agency-appointed judges.

Perhaps most significantly, the Supreme Court overturned Chevron deference with its decision in Loper Bright. This move was seen as a step towards restoring checks and balances within the government, reinforcing constitutional separation of powers.

Looking ahead to 2025, there are expectations for further opportunities to advance civil liberties and ensure government remains a protector of these rights.

Organizations in this story