Dean, Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy | Official website
+ Legislature
New Jersey Review | Aug 5, 2025

Dean Shapiro comments on implications of BLS commissioner’s firing by President Trump

President Donald Trump’s recent dismissal of Erika McEntarfer, commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), has raised concerns about the independence and reliability of federal data. The action followed a significant downward revision in job gains estimates by the BLS, after which Trump labeled the numbers as “rigged” and accused McEntarfer of falsifying data, though he did not present evidence to support his claims.

The incident highlights ongoing tensions between political leaders and federal statistical agencies. Official government statistics play a crucial role for policymakers, businesses, and investors who depend on this information for decision-making.

Stuart Shapiro, dean of the public policy school at Rutgers University and author of “Trump and the Bureaucrats: The Fate of Neutral Competence,” commented on the situation: “The Trump administration … has made no secret about its desire to get rid of people who are trained in their jobs if they are not loyal to the current president.”

Shapiro also warned about possible future developments: “Schedule F will likely be put in place soon,” he adds. “And we will see another very dramatic example of that trend when that happens.”

The firing is seen by some observers as part of a broader pattern within the administration to replace experienced officials with individuals perceived as more loyal.

Organizations in this story